Orcs are a fantasy monster. While Tolkien may have standardized them as the basic low-level mook hounding the protagonists, the idea of the orc goes back millennia before. The word "orc" is an Anglicization of the Italian word "orco", which is a kind of monstrous demon of Italian fairy tales that feeds on human flesh. This is identical to "ogre" in classic French fairy tales, which became its own type of monster in the modern era.
The orco takes its name from Orcus, one of the Roman gods of the underworld. Orcus was particularly associated with torment and punishment, and therefore also associated with evil and demons. He was normally depicted as a giant hairy monster.
Tuesday, April 28, 2020
Monday, April 20, 2020
How I came to DCC and the Old School of Gaming
Smaug, from the only feature-length adaptation of the Hobbit |
One day, between about 8 and 11 years old, I discovered my dad's copy of Gary Gygax's original DMG for AD&D (the one with the metal-girded demon abducting a maiden), and his copy of Dr. Eric Holmes' Basic Ruleset (the blue cover with the dragon on his hoard of gold).
I was immediately sold.
Cover of Holmes' Basic Rules |
Tuesday, April 14, 2020
The Letter for the King: just adapt the book, not your fanfiction
I recently watched The Letter for the King on Netflix, and thought I'd offer a small thought on the series.
I should preface all of this by stating that I have never read the book. I had actually never heard of the book. I looked up the book later on Wikipedia, after watching the first episode. I might actually read the book.
That out of the way, let me list some positives of the series. The child actors are great. I can't say the same about whoever it was playing the puppy-kicking prince, but the others made great performances. The visual effects were great. The costumes and props and sets were great. A lot of people clearly put a lot of effort and thought and care into the series. It shows through.
But some other people didn't put any effort in. Namely, the writers. The writers did not care. That also shows through.
I should preface all of this by stating that I have never read the book. I had actually never heard of the book. I looked up the book later on Wikipedia, after watching the first episode. I might actually read the book.
That out of the way, let me list some positives of the series. The child actors are great. I can't say the same about whoever it was playing the puppy-kicking prince, but the others made great performances. The visual effects were great. The costumes and props and sets were great. A lot of people clearly put a lot of effort and thought and care into the series. It shows through.
But some other people didn't put any effort in. Namely, the writers. The writers did not care. That also shows through.
Monday, May 27, 2019
The Wheel of Time and the Well-Tempered Plot Device
Sometime back in 2011, I was handed a complete (used!) set of Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time Series from a friend who saw me reading A Song of Ice and Fire. For several years it sat on my office desk, because I got caught up in other writers. Then it sat on my bookshelf for a few years as I got caught up in work and research, before I finally picked up the Eye of the World and decided to read it last fall.
With a TV adaptation proposed to come out sometime in the near future, I figured now was as good a time as any for a post about it.
With a TV adaptation proposed to come out sometime in the near future, I figured now was as good a time as any for a post about it.
Sunday, May 19, 2019
JK Rowling and Sanderson's 3rd Law
The Harry Potter books succeeded wildly, beyond anyone's imagination. JK Rowling is the top-selling author of all time. Not just in fantasy. Period. I believe the series did so well largely because of the strength of the characters and their relationships. Modern people want friendships like we see in Harry Potter and Stranger Things. So there's a lesson to potential authors. The characters and friendships of Harry Potter are incredible, and I can understand why so many people would love the stories on that basis.
Harry Potter succeeded because of its characters and relationships. But Harry Potter did not succeed because of its imagination.
I've spoken in depth in the past about why I don't like the Harry Potter books. All of it can be boiled down to a single statement:
But I stumbled on a more authoritative way to say this, in terms of Brandon Sanderson and his "laws of magic."
Harry Potter succeeded because of its characters and relationships. But Harry Potter did not succeed because of its imagination.
I've spoken in depth in the past about why I don't like the Harry Potter books. All of it can be boiled down to a single statement:
The characters of Harry Potter are unaware of their own universe.
But I stumbled on a more authoritative way to say this, in terms of Brandon Sanderson and his "laws of magic."
Sunday, November 18, 2018
Sagan's Anti-Dragon
In my garage I have an imaginary dragon. It's not real. Its just imaginary. It's a dragon made entirely of the good thoughts and happy feelings of people who like to think there's a dragon out there, somewhere, watching over them. But dragons aren't real, and neither is the dragon in my garage.
I tell you this, and you tell me that the dragon isn't imaginary. You insist it's a real dragon that is really in my garage. So I take you to my garage to show you that it's only imaginary.
We both immediately notice that the dragon is visible. You tell me that you can see it, and ask if I can see it. I can see it. And it's interesting that I'm seeing the dragon, and certainly counts for something.
I tell you this, and you tell me that the dragon isn't imaginary. You insist it's a real dragon that is really in my garage. So I take you to my garage to show you that it's only imaginary.
We both immediately notice that the dragon is visible. You tell me that you can see it, and ask if I can see it. I can see it. And it's interesting that I'm seeing the dragon, and certainly counts for something.
Tuesday, August 14, 2018
The Shaggydog Theory: Why George R. R. Martin Doesn't Want to Finish his Song of Ice and Fire Series
Seven years ago, the last update to the legendary A Song of Ice and Fire series came available, the fifth book A Dance with Dragons. This book was somewhat disappointing to fans of the series. The books failed to have any of the juicy details readers actually wanted, being not-so-affectionately labeled "Traveling Places and Administrative Tasks: The Book". The book was also a major disappointment because it came out over five years after the previous book, A Feast For Crows, released in 2005, despite the promise of Martin that the fifth book would be released speedily since he had already written most of it when he divided the upcoming fourth novel into two separate novels.
And then the fourth book came out five years after the book before it, and was also something of a disappointment. While the third book had betrayals and kingdom-spanning adventures for the future of the continent, the Feast was much slower-paced and almost seems a tangent compared to the promise of the original three books. Almost none of the plot lines were picked up, meaning it was over a decade, when Dragons was released, that fans got to go back to the characters they last read about in 2000 when A Storm of Swords was released.
In the intervening years, Ol' Georgie has been quite busy.... just not busy with anything to do with the book series that has sold millions of copies and was made into the most-pirated television series in history. Martin has been instead going on tours and writing all kinds of other stories. Some are tangentially related to the world of Westeros, others not so much.
And then the fourth book came out five years after the book before it, and was also something of a disappointment. While the third book had betrayals and kingdom-spanning adventures for the future of the continent, the Feast was much slower-paced and almost seems a tangent compared to the promise of the original three books. Almost none of the plot lines were picked up, meaning it was over a decade, when Dragons was released, that fans got to go back to the characters they last read about in 2000 when A Storm of Swords was released.
In the intervening years, Ol' Georgie has been quite busy.... just not busy with anything to do with the book series that has sold millions of copies and was made into the most-pirated television series in history. Martin has been instead going on tours and writing all kinds of other stories. Some are tangentially related to the world of Westeros, others not so much.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)